Lone Atrial Fibrillation
by Hans R. Larsen, MSc ChE
A steady, inconspicuous heartbeat is usually taken for granted so when an attack of atrial fibrillation strikes it is a very frightening experience. The heart beats wildly with a pulse rate as high as 200 beats/minute, dizziness and breathlessness and even fainting may follow and chest pain, extreme fatigue and the need for frequent urination are common symptoms. Fibrillation attack victims usually experience one or more of these symptoms, but a few patients are not aware of any symptoms at all until an electrocardiogram exposes their irregular heart rhythm(1-4).
Atrial fibrillation is the most common cardiac arrhythmia and affects more than 1.5 million Americans. Its primary characteristic is a rapid and irregular heartbeat. The incidence of atrial fibrillation shows a significant increase beyond the age of 50 years and the condition is considerably more common among men than among women. Atrial fibrillation may be chronic or intermittent (paroxysmal) and may be triggered by an underlying heart disease such as mitral valve prolapse or stenosis, coronary artery disease, hypertensive heart disease, a heart attack or an inflammation of the membrane surrounding the heart (pericarditis). Atrial fibrillation is also a common complication of heart surgery(1-3,5-7).
Lone Atrial Fibrillation.
Lone atrial fibrillation (LAF) may be an isolated event or it may recur on an intermittent basis; it is rarely chronic. It is significantly more prevalent among men than among women. An attack may last a few hours or several days, but rarely longer than a week. The frequency of attacks in intermittent LAF may vary from less than one a year to three per year or more(4,8). Lone atrial fibrillation caused by an overactive thyroid gland (hyperthyroidism) is fairly common and can usually be eliminated by dealing with the underlying disease(1,2,5,6,7,9)
LAF may also be triggered by hypoglycemia, surgery, chronic infections, alcohol abuse (especially binge drinking), nicotine and caffeine (coffee and cola drinks)(1,2,7,9,10). An allergic reaction may also act as a trigger. Thyramine-containing foods such as cheese, red wine, yogurt, bananas, and chocolate have been known to trigger LAF attacks(11). Serious electrolyte imbalances, such as between sodium and potassium and between calcium and magnesium are other potent triggers for arrhythmias(5,9,12).
Many drugs, chief among them digitalis (digoxin, Lanoxin) and other antiarrhythmic drugs, may trigger atrial fibrillation as may excessive physical and emotional stress(1-3,5,10,13).
The rhythm of the heart is controlled through a fine balance of input from the parasympathetic (vagal nerve) and sympathetic nervous system. Thus events, which disturb either of these systems, may trigger LAF. Dr. Philippe Coumel, MD, a French cardiologist, has done extensive work on the link between the nervous system and LAF. He has identified a vagal form of LAF which is most common among men aged 40 to 50, occurs during the night, at rest, after eating or following intake of alcohol. This type of LAF may be triggered by sudden stimulation of the vagal nerve through, for example, vomiting or violent sneezing. Dr. Coumel also describes an adrenergic (adrenal hormone linked) form of LAF which occurs exclusively during daytime and which is often preceded by exercise or emotional stress. Frequent urination is a common feature of this type of LAF(3,13).
Dr. Abram Hoffer, MD, a prominent Canadian physician, also believes that many LAF attacks are caused by excessive physical or emotional stress. He postulates that adrenochrome, a metabolite of adrenaline (epinephrine) is the culprit that initiates LAF attacks. Dr. Hoffer also believes that adrenochrome's negative effects can be negated by certain antioxidants(14).
It is clear that there are many types and potential triggers for LAF and this, of course, makes treatment and prevention extremely complicated and difficult.
Emergency treatment of arrhythmias
Electric cardioversion is used in serious cases to re-establish regular heart rhythm once the pulse rate has been lowered(2,7,17). However, in many cases, sinus rhythm is re-established spontaneously. Cardioversion is not very effective when it comes to LAF and is not recommended for this condition(18).
Many clinical trials have shown magnesium injections to be very effective in stopping fibrillation attacks and some doctors now advocate its routine use in the emergency department. Unfortunately, no studies have been made yet to evaluate the benefits of oral magnesium supplementation in the prevention of LAF(19-24).
Drugs such as procainamide, quinidine, flecainide, sotalol and amiodarone may also be successful in many cases in restoring sinus rhythm. However, these drugs are dangerous and their effect often transient(5,17,25). There is no clear consensus that they are of any value in treating LAF, especially not in cases where symptoms are relatively mild(25).
Atrial fibrillation patients usually also receive aspirin or warfarin when treated in the emergency ward. The irregular beating of the heart may result in the formation of blood clots in people with heart disease and if these clots get stuck in the narrow blood vessels in the brain a stroke may result. There is now compelling evidence that heart disease patients with atrial fibrillation can lessen their risk of a stroke significantly by taking an anticoagulant such as warfarin on a regular basis(2,3,5,7,17).
There is however, considerable controversy as to the benefits of anticoagulation therapy in the case of LAF patients, that is, patients with no underlying heart disease, hypertension or other specific risk factors for ischemic stroke (stroke caused by a blood clot). Several studies have found that LAF sufferers do not seem to have a higher risk of stroke than does the general public and therefore may not benefit from taking warfarin or aspirin on a regular basis(5,7,9,15). Researchers at the Mayo Clinic believe that routine anticoagulation is unwarranted for LAF patients under the age of 60 years and that the dangers (internal bleeding, stomach ulcers) of such therapy significantly outweigh the benefits(10). Italian researchers found no difference in the incidence of stroke among LAF patients under 70 years of age regardless of whether they received anticoagulation therapy or not(8).
Prevention of recurrence of LAF
Other antiarrhythmic drugs such as quinidine, amiodarone, propranolol, sotalol and flecainide may be effective in preventing some types of LAF, but may have no effect on others or may actually aggravate the situation. All antiarrhythmic drugs have very serious side effects and may cause life-threatening arrhythmias themselves. Several clinical trials have shown that patients treated with quinidine and other antiarrhythmic drugs have a higher mortality rate than do patients who are left untreated(3,5,7,15-17,25,29).
Although there is no clear consensus regarding antiarrhythmic drugs in the treatment of LAF many experts believe that their use should be limited to cases where symptoms are severe and persistent(17,25,29).
Fortunately, there are several alternative approaches that show promise in preventing LAF.
Dr. Matthias Rath, MD, a leading American expert on cardiovascular disease, believes that arrhythmias are primarily caused by nutritional deficiencies and can be prevented by optimizing the intake of such nutrients as vitamin-C, l-carnitine, coenzyme Q10, magnesium and vitamin B complex(30). Magnesium is of particular importance as it is highly concentrated in the heart muscle and counteracts excessive calcium, which tends to excite the heart. L-carnitine has been found to have excellent antiarrhythmic properties and is also useful in the treatment of heart attack patients and patients with intermittent claudication(31- 33).
Dr. Abram Hoffer, MD reports excellent results in the prevention of LAF through the use of mega-doses of niacin and folic acid(14).
Japanese researchers have found coenzyme Q10 to be effective in the management of arrhythmias(34-36).
Hawthorn (Crataegus oxyacantha) is widely used in the management of arrhythmias in Europe. It is non-toxic and has been found to improve the overall performance of the heart(37-39).
The bottom line
The first step in preventing LAF attacks is, of course, to avoid the trigger factors. Staying away from alcohol, caffeine and antiarrhythmic drugs such as digoxin is extremely important. Foods that may cause an allergic reaction should be avoided, as should excessive physical and emotional stress.
There is no magic drug, which will prevent LAF, and the ones frequently prescribed for the condition are likely to do more harm than good. Elimination of nutritional deficiencies and judicious, medically- supervised supplementation with magnesium, l-carnitine, coenzyme Q10, hawthorn, niacin, folic acid, and the vitamin B complex can however, go a long way towards preventing recurrence of LAF attacks.