EDITORIALThere is a growing trend in medical literature to report research results in relative rather than absolute terms. Let me explain. In this issue we report that men who drink 6 cups of water per day have a 51 per cent lower relative risk of developing bladder cancer than do men who drink 1 cup or less per day. Sounds impressive, but what does it actually mean? Looking closer at the study data it is clear that the total incidence of bladder cancer over a 10-year period was 0.59 per cent among men drinking 1 cup or less per day as compared to 0.33 per cent among men drinking 6 or more cups per day. Not quite so impressive a difference when presented in absolute rather than relative terms!Pharmaceutical drug manufacturers are notorious for using relative benefits rather than absolute benefits in their advertising. Warfarin (Coumadin) is a case in point. Warfarin is aggressively promoted for the prevention of a first stroke in patients suffering from non-valvular atrial fibrillation. Dupont's promotional literature claims that warfarin will reduce the risk of ischemic stroke by 68 per cent in these patients. Sounds like a good deal?! Perhaps, but not only is the 68 per cent arrived at by combining a mish-mash of studies involving people with widely different risks of stroke, but it also fails to emphasize the very serious bleeding complications inherent in warfarin therapy. For instance, a large study carried out in British Columbia found that the combined annual incidence of fatal stroke and bleeding was 0.42 per cent among warfarin-treated patients with chronic non- valvular atrial fibrillation - the same as the incidence in the non-treated (control) group. Other studies have found warfarin therapy to confer a 2 per cent absolute benefit in selected patients. The Cochrane Collection, a prestigious medical think-tank, sums up the "benefits" of warfarin therapy as follows: "The margin between benefit and harm for warfarin prophylaxis in patients with chronic non-valvular atrial fibrillation is uncomfortably thin. The low absolute risk reductions observed in trials would likely be overwhelmed in less controlled settings by problems associated with the use of warfarin". So while a 68 per cent relative reduction in stroke risk may sound impressive, the absolute risk reduction is much less impressive particularly when the serious side effects are considered. Also while this risk reduction may apply on the average, it is by no means certain in specific cases. For instance, one large study found no advantage in using warfarin for lone atrial fibrillation. The bottom line is that claimed relative risk or symptom reductions may not be that significant when closely scrutinized. Unfortunately, many physicians go by the drug manufacturers' claims when prescribing. A recent survey found that 80 per cent of doctors would prescribe gemfibrozil (a cholesterol-lowering drug) if told that it would reduce cardiac events by 34 per cent (in relative terms). However, when told that the absolute reduction in cardiac events was only 1.4 per cent less than 25 per cent of the doctors agreed to prescribe the drug. It seems like the old adage "patient beware" is still alive and well! Yours in health, Hans R. Larsen, Editor |
LETTERS TO THE EDITORI have read your article "Parkinson's Disease: Is Victory in Sight?" A friend of mine is suffering from Parkinson's disease. She is under the age of 50 and the doctors have found too high a level of mercury toxicity. It is suspected that this is caused by her amalgam fillings. At the moment her dentist is replacing her fillings and if necessary will pull out her teeth. She is also on certain pills to get the mercury out of her body, a process which will take considerable time. Can you advise on anything further that can be done?Mieps, Holland Editor: Having read my article I am sure you are aware of the importance of supplementing with relatively large amounts of antioxidants (vitamins C and E). Proanthocyanidins (grape seed extract) may also be helpful. Hopefully, the amalgam removal will help. Here in Canada an injection of DMPS (sodium 2,3-dimercaptopropane-1-sulfonate) is often used to speed up the removal of mercury residues once ALL the amalgam fillings have been removed. During the removal process garlic and a cracked cell wall chlorella (Sun Chlorella) may be useful. I am looking for information on coumadin. My mother's level keeps going up and down. She is in and out of hospital. She had major heart surgery in December at the age of 68. She is also a diabetic. What can we do? Can diet, etc. control this? Joni, USA Editor: I can think of a few things that may affect the INR (anticoagulation) results. It is essential to take the coumadin tablet(s) at exactly the same time each day. Diet can certainly affect readings. Foods high in vitamin K (kale, green tea, spinach, broccoli, etc.) and vitamin K itself will lower INR readings. Many herbs can drastically affect INR values. Ginseng, ginger, Ginkgo biloba, and feverfew lower INR while dan- shen (a Chinese herb) increases it. Other herbs that may affect INR are arnica, chamomille, celery, fenugreek, and garlic. Various disease conditions such as edema, hyperlipemia, hypothyroidism, and nephrotic syndrome can affect INR as can many pharmaceutical drugs (including oral diabetes agents) and prolonged hot weather. I have been searching the Internet for information on coenzyme A. I saw information on this coenzyme in the June 1999 issue of Energy Times. It sounds like it may be a missing supplement in my regimen based on what I read on this website (www.Coenzyme-A.com). Do you know anything about this coenzyme, its importance, and where I might find further information on the subject? Andy, USA Editor: I have read the information about coenzyme A on the above mentioned website and found it to be generally accurate. Certainly the functions of coenzyme A are many and varied and a deficiency could undoubtedly lead to health problems. Coenzyme A is manufactured in the body from the B vitamin pantothenic acid. It cannot be taken as a supplement on its own as it would not survive a trip through the stomach. This is why the Coenzyme-A Technologies product consists of pantothenic acid and some other components which may facilitate its conversion to coenzyme A in the body. I have not come across any medical evidence which would indicate that people with an adequate intake of pantothenic acid would be likely to suffer from a coenzyme A deficiency. Pantothenic acid is widely available in food and can, of course, also be taken as a supplement. Dr. Lit-Hung Leung, MD, a pioneer in coenzyme A/pantothenic acid research, recommends 2-3 grams/day of pantothenic acid for weight loss and added zest and energy.
|
ABSTRACTS
DHEA helps chronic fatigue patients
WAKEFIELD, RHODE ISLAND. DHEA (dehydroepiandrosterone) is the primary
hormone secreted from the adrenal gland. It is synthesized from cholesterol
through pregnenolone and is metabolized into estrogens and testosterone.
DHEA is found in blood serum as the sulfate (DHEA-S). Medical research has
shown that patients with rheumatoid arthritis, premenopausal breast cancer or
chronic severe illness have subnormal DHEA-S levels. Now researchers at the
University of Rhode Island report that women suffering from chronic fatigue
syndrome (CFS) also have excessively low DHEA-S levels and that their
symptoms can be markedly reduced by oral supplementation with DHEA. The
experiment involved 23 white women between the ages of 35 and 55 years who
had been diagnosed with CFS and whose blood levels of DHEA-S were below 2.0
micrograms/mL (normal levels for this age group is 0.7 to 3.0 micrograms/mL).
The extent of the women's physical and psychological impairment was measured
at the start of the experiment and at three-month intervals thereafter. The
women initially were given a 25 mg tablet of DHEA daily and their DHEA-S
level was measured every four to six weeks. If levels were still below 2
micrograms/mL the dose was increased to a maximum of 100 mg/day. At the end
of six months the average daily dose was 58.15 mg. Average blood levels of
DHEA-S increased from an initial level of 0.88 microgram/mL to 4.12
micrograms/mL at six months. Free testosterone levels increased by a factor
of 2.5, low density cholesterol levels declined by 7.4 per cent, and high
density cholesterol declined by 13 per cent. After six months of treatment
pain severity among the women had decreased by an average of 18 per cent,
depression and anxiety scores decreased by 17 per cent and 35 per cent
respectively, and memory and the ability to think clearly improved by 17 per
cent and 26 per cent respectively. The researchers conclude that the DHEA
supplementation significantly improved the quality of life of the CFS
patients and urge further studies. NOTE: This study was partially funded by
Allergy Research Nutricology.
Smoking and ulcerative colitis
ROCHESTER, MINNESOTA. Smoking is decidedly unhealthy and addictive and has
been clearly linked to a vastly increased risk of cardiovascular disease,
cancer, emphyzema, and osteoporosis. Now and then though, medical evidence
of possible benefits of nicotine and even of smoking as such does emerge.
Several studies have shown that the prevalence of ulcerative colitis (UC) is
three to five times higher among never-smokers than among smokers. There is
also evidence that smokers who give up the habit are at increased risk for UC
and that the disease can be put into remission by resuming or initiating
smoking (in non-smokers). Researchers at the Mayo Clinic report that
nicotine patches (30 mg delivering 22 mg of nicotine) are effective in
putting UC into remission especially among former smokers. Nicotine gum also
works for former smokers, but was found to be of no benefit for never-
smokers. Very recent research has also shown that time-release oral nicotine
tartrate capsules or nicotine tartrate enemas reliably increase the blood
concentrations of nicotine with very few side effects. The Mayo Clinic
researchers urge further studies to determine if this approach will be
effective in putting UC into remission.
Children should sleep in the dark
PHILADELPHIA, PENNSYLVANIA. Myopia (short-sightedness) is becoming
increasingly prevalent and now affects 70-90 per cent of some Asian
populations. Myopia can be corrected with eye glasses or contact lenses.
Nevertheless, it is a leading cause of blindness among adults because it
predisposes to glaucoma and retinal detachment. Researchers at the
University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine now report that nighttime light
exposure prior to the age of two years is strongly linked to the incidence of
myopia in later life. Their study involved 479 children aged 2-16 years (70
per cent Caucasian, 30 per cent African-American). Between January and June
1998 parents whose children were seen at the University's ophthalmology
clinic were asked whether their children had slept in the dark, with a room
light on or with a night-light (about four watt strength) between birth and
the age of two years as well as later on in their childhood. One hundred and
seventy of the children had slept in the dark, 75 with room light, and 232
with night-light. In correlating the presence of myopia with the amount of
nighttime light the children had been exposed to the researchers made a
fascinating discovery. Fifty-five per cent of the children who had been
exposed to room light at night during their first two years of life had
myopia. Among the "night-light children" 34 per cent had myopia, but among
the children who had slept in the dark only 10 per cent had myopia. Overall,
66 per cent of the children who had slept in the dark had normal vision as
compared to 50 per cent in the night-light group and 29 per cent in the room
light group. The researchers urge more studies to confirm their findings,
but for now recommend that infants and young children sleep at night without
artificial lighting.
Melatonin may reduce risk of heart attack
MODENA, ITALY. It is a well known fact that the incidence of heart attacks
peaks in the morning and is much lower during the night when blood pressure
and catecholamine (epinephrine and norepinephrine) levels are low.
Researchers at the University of Modena speculated that melatonin which is
secreted almost exclusively at night could somehow be involved in this change
in the activity of the cardiovascular system. They have just released a
report of a study carried out to test this hypothesis. Fourteen normal,
healthy men aged 23 to 29 years were involved in the double-blind study. On
the first of two consecutive days the men received either 1 mg melatonin
(powder) or a placebo on a random basis. On the second day the alternate
treatment was administered. All treatments were carried out between 2:30 and
5:30 PM. After resting for 90 minutes in the supine position the men had an
echocardiogram taken, their blood pressure measured, and blood samples drawn.
An analysis of the collected data showed that melatonin levels in the blood
had increased from an average of 12 pmol/L to 6360 pmol/L on the day the
participants received melatonin. Systolic blood pressure decreased by about
10 per cent (9 mm Hg) with the melatonin supplementation and norepinephrine
concentration also declined significantly. There were no significant changes
in epinephrine (adrenaline) concentration or pulse rate. The echocardiogram
showed improved blood flow in the carotid artery. The researchers point out
that all the changes achieved by melatonin supplementation are highly
beneficial to heart activity and that the blood pressure drop alone
corresponds to a 20 per cent reduction in cardiovascular mortality. They
conclude that low melatonin levels, such as found in many elderly people, may
constitute an important risk factor for cardiovascular disease and urge
further studies to evaluate the potential benefits of melatonin
supplementation.
Levodopa for Parkinson's disease: helpful or harmful?
NEW YORK, NY. Levodopa has been the mainstay pharmaceutical drug for the
treatment of Parkinson's disease (PD) for more than 30 years. Although
levodopa is effective initially in ameliorating some of the symptoms of PD
its effects tend to wear off after a few years. It is estimated that 75 per
cent of PD patients treated with levodopa develop serious adverse effects
within five years. The most common of these are an increase in involuntary
muscle movements (dyskinesias) and a pronounced "on-off" phenomenon where PD
symptoms oscillate between "bad" and "not so bad". Patients who develop PD
before the age of 40 are more likely to develop dyskinesias than are older
patients. Concern has been raised that levodopa itself contributes
significantly to oxidative stress in the brain which could lead to an
accelerated loss of neurons. Because of levodopa's serious adverse effects
many neurologists now recommend that levodopa treatment be delayed as long as
possible. A recent survey of 120 neurologists showed that over 85 per cent
of them would delay treatment in younger patients and 75 per cent would delay
it in older patients. Many neurologists believe that levodopa may actually
speed up the progression of PD. In view of this concern the Parkinson Study
Group will now undertake a major study involving 360 patients to determine
whether this is indeed the case. They will also try to establish how long it
takes for levodopa to lose its beneficial effects, how common fatigue is
among patients with early disease, and how early initiation and dosage of
levodopa affects PD symptoms and the patients' quality of life. (Editor's
Note: It is indeed unfortunate that this study was not done before the
drug was introduced into general use 30 years ago.)
Drinking water now polluted with pharmaceuticals
COPENHAGEN, DENMARK. Much attention has been focused on the problem of
pesticide pollution of drinking water. Now scientists warn of another
danger. It appears that pollution with pharmaceutical drugs and their
residues is reaching the levels of pesticide pollution. A recent study in
Berlin found significant amounts of antibiotics, ibuprofen, cholesterol-
lowering drugs, hormones (estrogen), and chemotherapy agents in that city's
water supply. Swiss researchers have found cholesterol-lowering drugs in
lakes and a British scientist estimates that more than a ton of aspirin and a
ton of morphine derivatives flow down one small river in northeast London
every year. The drugs originate from human and animal urine and from
pharmaceutical waste products which are dumped either on land or in the sea.
Says Danish pharmacist Bent Halling-Sorensen "Between 30 and 90 per cent of
an administered dose of most antibiotics to humans and animals is excreted
with the urine." The problem is particularly acute in the fish-farming
industry where, according to Halling-Sorensen, 70 to 80 per cent of drugs
administered end up in the environment. The biggest concern of scientists
just now beginning to study the problem is that the drugs in the environment
and drinking water could profoundly affect the hormone systems of both
animals and humans and contribute significantly to the further spread of
resistance to antibiotics.
Increased fluid intake helps prevent bladder cancer
BOSTON, MASSACHUSETTS. Bladder cancer is the fourth leading type of cancer
among men in the United States; worldwide about 310,000 new cases were
diagnosed in 1996. Researchers at the Harvard School of Public Health now
report that men can reduce their risk of developing bladder cancer by
increasing their intake of fluids especially water. The study involved
almost 48,000 male health professionals who provided information about their
dietary intake including fluid intake in 1986, 1990, and 1994. During a 10-
year follow-up period 252 (0.6 per cent) of the men developed bladder cancer.
The researchers confirmed that age and smoking are the two main risk factors
for bladder cancer. Men with a history of 65 or more pack-years of smoking
had a 3.7 times higher risk than never-smokers. Men aged between 70 and 79
years had a six times greater risk than men under 50 years of age and men 80
years and older had an 11.6 fold higher risk. The researchers also
discovered that men with a high fluid intake (greater than 2531 ml (10 cups)
per day) had half the risk of developing bladder cancer than did men whose
fluid intake was less than 1290 ml (5 cups per day) after adjustment for age
and smoking status. The risk reduction was particularly evident in the case
of water. Men who drank six or more cups (1440 ml) of water per day had a 51
per cent lower risk of bladder cancer than did men who drank less than one
cup (240 ml) per day. Overall, an increase in water intake of one cup per
day was found to decrease bladder cancer risk by seven per cent. The
researchers speculate that the increased fluid intake leads to a greater
frequency of urination resulting in less contact time between the bladder
wall and carcinogens in the urine.
Vitamin C and diabetes
ATLANTA, GEORGIA. Several studies have found that diabetics have lower blood
levels of vitamin C than do healthy people. Researchers at the Centers for
Disease Control and Prevention recently compared 237 patients with newly
diagnosed diabetes with 1803 persons without diabetes and concluded that
vitamin C levels were indeed lower in the diabetics. This held true even
when adjusting for age and sex. However, once adjustments for total vitamin
C intake, smoking, alcohol consumption, education, body mass index, race, and
physical activity level were included there were no significant differences
in vitamin C levels among the two groups. The researchers conclude that it
is necessary to account for all factors affecting serum vitamin C
concentrations when comparing levels in diabetics and non-diabetics. An even
more intriguing finding derived from the study is the fact that the healthy
group of people tended to have a significantly larger average intake of
vitamin C supplements (265 mg/day) than did the diabetics (160 mg/day). The
vitamin C contribution from food was similar in both groups at 104
mg/day.
Fish oils and manic-depressive illness
BOSTON, MASSACHUSETTS. Manic-depressive illness (bipolar disorder) is a
common, severe mental illness involving repeated episodes of depression,
mania (rapid mood changes, hyperactivity, and excessive cheerfulness) or
both. It is usually treated with drugs such as lithium carbonate or
valproate. Unfortunately, these drugs are not very effective and recurrence
rates are high. It is generally believed that bipolar disorder involves an
overactivity in the neuronal signal pathways. Omega-3 fatty acids are known
to dampen this overactivity and the hypothesis has been advanced that they
may be useful in the treatment of bipolar disorder. Medical scientists have
now confirmed this in a landmark study just completed at the Harvard Medical
School. The double-blind, placebo-controlled study involved 30 patients (men
and women 18 to 65 years of age) who had all been diagnosed with bipolar
disorder. Half the patients were given seven fish oil capsules twice a day
while the placebo group were given seven olive oil capsules twice a day.
Each fish oil capsule contained 440 mg of eicosapentaenoic acid and 240 mg
of docosahexaenoic acid. All of the participants except four in the fish oil
group and four in the placebo group also continued to receive a standard
mood-stabilizing drug prescribed previously. The mental state of the
participants was measured using four scales (Clinical Global Impression
Scale, Global Assessment Scale, Young Mania Rating Scale, and the Hamilton
Rating Scale for Depression) at the start of the study and after two, four,
six, eight, twelve and sixteen weeks. Twelve of the 14 participants in the
fish oil group completed the four-month study without major episodes of mania
or depression as compared to only six out of 16 participants in the placebo
group. Also, while nine of the placebo group members experienced worsening
depression none of the fish oil group members did. The four patients in the
fish oil group who had not been prescribed mood-stabilizing drugs all
completed the study without major episodes, but only one member in the
placebo group not on mood-stabilizing drugs did. The average decline in
depression rating on the Hamilton Scale was almost 50 per cent in the fish
oil group as compared to an increase of 25 per cent in the control group.
The Harvard researchers urge further trials of fish oils in the treatment of
depression and manic-depressive illness.
Vitamin C and the common cold
HELSINKI, FINLAND. The effect of vitamin C on the common cold has been a
matter of considerable controversy ever since the early 1970s when Linus
Pauling suggested that vitamin C supplementation could prevent or ameliorate
the symptoms of a cold. Some subsequent studies have confirmed Dr. Pauling's
findings while others have found no beneficial effects. Dr. Harri Hemila of
the Finnish Department of Public Health has just released a comprehensive
report which analyzes the results of 23 studies involving supplementation
with 1 gram/day or more of vitamin C. Dr. Hemila concludes that regular
supplementation with vitamin C (more than 1 gram/day) does indeed decrease
the severity of a cold. The beneficial effect is considerably more
pronounced among children than among adults and increases with increasing
intake. In five studies evaluating the effect of supplementation with 1
gram/day in adults the average reduction in cold severity was only 6 per
cent. However, when 2 grams/day was administered to children a reduction of
26 per cent was observed. It is also clear that the effect is highly dose
dependent. Dr. Hemila estimates that it would take 10 grams/day of vitamin C
(regular supplementation) to reduce cold severity in adults by 50 per cent
whereas children would only need 3.9 grams/day to achieve the same effect.
Although only a few studies have been done on the effects of initiating
vitamin supplementation once the the cold starts (therapeutic
supplementation) it would appear that the benefits of a five-day therapeutic
regimen may be similar to that of continuous supplementation. Dr. Hemila
urges further studies to determine the optimum doses for therapeutic
supplementation which would probably range somewhere between 10 and 30
grams/day for adults. (54 references)
Cholesterol reduction in heart attack victims
TURIN, ITALY. It is generally believed that heart attack victims benefit
from lowering their cholesterol levels by dietary changes, drugs (statins) or
supplements (garlic, bran, etc). Now medical researchers at the University
of Turin question this assumption. Their study involved 192 men and 112
women with a mean age of 73 years who had been discharged from hospital
between 1988 and 1991 after suffering an acute myocardial infarction (heart
attack). At the end of 1995 129 (67 per cent) of the men and 69 (62 per
cent) of the women had died - about 30 per cent of them from heart disease.
The researchers correlated the cholesterol levels of the patients (at the
time of the infarction) with their risk of death and found that there was no
correlation between cholesterol levels and mortality from heart disease or
any other cause. Patients with a level above 6.25 mmol/L (245 mg/dL) were
just as likely to die within the study period as were patients with levels
below 6.25 mmol/L - or even below 4.44 mmol/L (175 mg/dL). The researchers
conclude that there is no association between total cholesterol levels and
mortality either due to heart disease or other causes in men and women of age
65 years or older who have suffered a heart attack.
Please send us a message if you need Reprint Information
|
NEWSBRIEFS
Wealth ensures better cancer survival
Alternative medicine popular for inflammatory bowel disease
Panic attacks linked to gene defect
Battle lines drawn on genetic engineering.
|
BOOK REVIEW
Numb Toes and Aching Soles: A recent survey concluded that millions of Americans suffer from peripheral neuropathy and don't even know it. This "silent" disease, far more common than rheumatoid arthritis, is painful and debilitating and can certainly put a serious damper on one's enjoyment of life. Peripheral neuropathy (PN) results from damage to the peripheral nerves or their protective coatings and most often manifests itself by pain, tingling and numbness in the legs, feet and hands. The disorder may also present itself with vague symptoms such as dizziness, insomnia, bladder problems, constipation and sexual dysfunction. Because of its diverse symptoms PN is often misdiagnosed launching its victims on the all too familiar pattern of an increasingly desperate search for an explanation and cure.
John Senneff has suffered from PN for more than ten years and has been
through the gamut of tests and therapies himself. It is not extravagant to
claim that his superbly researched book contains all the information that a
patient or caregiver would ever need to know about PN. Diagnostic tests and
the benefits and side effects of pharmaceutical drugs, vitamins and herbs
used in the treatment of PN are described in great detail as are the
pertinent alternative modalities from acupuncture to hyperbaric oxygen
treatment. Twelve eminent neurologists provide detailed input to the book,
but perhaps its most fascinating aspect is the comments from more than 200 PN
patients describing their personal experiences with the many treatments
covered. They clearly show that what works for one person may be a waste of
time and money for another - but, they also give hope that successful
treatment is possible although the road to finding it may be long and
arduous. If you suffer from PN or know someone who does or if you are a
professional caring for PN patients order John's book now. It will save you
untold hours of time, trouble and pain in your battle against peripheral
neuropathy.
|
Victoria, BC, Canada V8S 1A5 Phone: (250) 384-2524 E-mail: health@pinc.com URL: http://vvv.com/healthnews/ ISSN 1203-1933.....Copyright © 1999 by Hans R. Larsen International Health News does not provide medical advice. Do not attempt self- diagnosis or self-medication based on our reports. Please consult your health-care provider if you wish to follow up on the information presented. |